| Alpha | |||||||
| East | South | ||||||
| 1 | Ryan Brooks | UConn | 1 | Mike Richards | Houston | ||
| 2 | Tim Nolan | Iowa St. | 2 | Scott Elliot | Marquette | ||
| 3 | Cheeta II | Illinois | 3 | Iain Brown | Kentucky | ||
| 4 | Stevie | Auburn | 4 | Daniel Welch | Duke | ||
| 5 | Greg Murphy | San Diego St. | 5 | Adam Thorell | Wisconsin | ||
| 6 | Cannonball | BYU | 6 | Cheeta I | Texas Tech | ||
| 7 | Dan Morrill | Washington St. | 7 | Cooper Maher | Florida | ||
| 8 | Dave McLean | FAU | 8 | Old Classic | Nebraska | ||
| 9 | Doug Houston | Northwestern | 9 | Matt Rocca | Texas A&M | ||
| 10 | Team Peeknuckle | Drake | 10 | Rob Croak | Boise St. / Colorado | ||
| 11 | Cheeta IV | Duquesne | 11 | Brian Plesser | NC State | ||
| 12 | Big Dog | UAB | 12 | Jason Roelke | James Madison | ||
| 13 | Chris Valentino | Yale | 13 | Dan Ardito | Vermont | ||
| 14 | Kyle Sullivan | Morehead St. | 14 | John Sheehy | Oakland | ||
| 15 | Luke Begley | So. Dakota St. | 15 | Chris Soriano | Western Kentucky | ||
| 16 | Tom Nolan | Stetson | 16 | David Brady | Longwood | ||
| MidWest | West | ||||||
| 1 | Sausage Sans Onion | Purdue | 1 | Mike Patton | North Carolina | ||
| 2 | Maura Nolan Brown | Tennessee | 2 | AJ Khoury | Arizona | ||
| 3 | Matthew Hepler | Creighton | 3 | Shaun Oliver | Baylor | ||
| 4 | Michael Sancomb | Kansas | 4 | Noles | Alabama | ||
| 5 | Dan Maher | Gonzaga | 5 | Mike Robey | St. Mary's | ||
| 6 | Marsy | South Carolina | 6 | Stever Roberts | Clemson | ||
| 7 | Cheeta V | Texas | 7 | Charlie Teeple | Dayton | ||
| 8 | Ryan Jennings | Utah St. | 8 | Tom Weierman | Mississippi St. | ||
| 9 | Rich Welch | TCU | 9 | Dave Abdou | Michigan St. | ||
| 10 | Lenny Nolan | Virginia / Colorado St. | 10 | Lou Monti | Nevada | ||
| 11 | Soup | Oregon | 11 | Griffin Ford | New Mexico | ||
| 12 | Pickles | McNeese | 12 | Bill Shields | Grand Canyon | ||
| 13 | Cheeta III | Samford | 13 | Derek Graves | Charleston | ||
| 14 | Nicole Emanuels | Akron | 14 | Andy Dow | Colgate | ||
| 15 | Jeff Croke | Saint Peter's | 15 | Josh Cooney | Long Beach St. | ||
| 16 | Michael Carew | Montana St. / Grambling | 16 | Michal D'onofrio | Howard / Wagner | ||